Monday, May 17, 2010

Exogeny

Game have seemingly been the hot topic in educational technology study for some time, always poised as the new revolution and the future of "learning in a networked world." However, they never quite seem to fit the bill, and any number of authors have tried to explain why.

It's clear that learning happens in games - without it, games would be flat, simplistic and boring. Players must learn, and must learn very complicated concepts quickly. However, WHAT they learn is not necessarily the point of the game, the point is the entertainment, learning is the mode.

I think this is where many educational games differ, and possibly where most educational game content will differ - "educational" games have a learning goal first, and use the entertainment as the mode. "Entertainment" games have an entertainment goal first, and use learning as the mode. Game designers have little concern for the skills, knowledge, or enduring understanding that their players have, so long as they understand enough/the right things to progress through the game. Educationalists, however, have a deep-seeded need to see success in an enduring understanding that was often chosen outside of the game mechanic entirely.

Thomas and Brown begin to touch on how this can be resolved, by understanding that the imposition of external learning forces for a game serves little, if not a negative, effect on the learning outcome of the game. Instead, they suggest, games have inherent learning that can be harnessed. I am inclined to subscribe to their thinking, however, I am concerned that that means we cannot use games as a tool, but rather that games will begin to decide what information can or cannot be learned (at least, through games). It almost seems lazy, to write off the ability of a game to be used as a mode in a learning objective.

I am a firm believing that game mechanics are highly effective in education. Games themselves, though, have yet to prove themselves useful in education. Or, maybe we have yet to allow them to prove themselves anything, for we're too busy telling them what they should be.

No comments:

Post a Comment