Monday, May 24, 2010

Opportunities for networked learning in the classroom

Technology, all too often, falls into the hands of those who know nothing but the status quo, and it is wasted to support outdated paradigms that "work", when it has so much more opportunity.

Stroup, Ares and Hurford discuss how the technology can go "beyond being there" - supporting ever more realistic role playing, and more immersive environments. Not only are students learning about mechanical or mathematical concepts, they claim, they're operating inside of them to do the studying itself.

I've been working in Simulation and Educational Technology at the Stanford University School of Medicine for a little over six months now, and the ways that medical students are receiving instruction today holds much of this research to light. The great majority of clinical study is done in simulation now, either virtual or mannequin-based, but always highly sophisticated so as to provide the most enriching, realistic experience to the student. Without these technologies, the students are left to study in books, and may only perform the procedures realistically on a real human being for the first time.

The anatomy department is working to secure funding right now for a virtual dissection table, a tool that a student could use to do exactly that - dissect a body. However, it isn't just an on-screen version of a cadaver. The table serves as an instant feedback mechanism, making student mistakes into instant teachable moments. It also makes the process highly social, even so far as allowing students in physically disconnected labs collaborate as if they were in the same room (or even better than that).

Medical instruction, given the high costs and logistical issues surrounding it, is prime for simulated and networked materials. It isn't the only field, though, and many others would be wise to follow suit.

Monday, May 17, 2010

Exogeny

Game have seemingly been the hot topic in educational technology study for some time, always poised as the new revolution and the future of "learning in a networked world." However, they never quite seem to fit the bill, and any number of authors have tried to explain why.

It's clear that learning happens in games - without it, games would be flat, simplistic and boring. Players must learn, and must learn very complicated concepts quickly. However, WHAT they learn is not necessarily the point of the game, the point is the entertainment, learning is the mode.

I think this is where many educational games differ, and possibly where most educational game content will differ - "educational" games have a learning goal first, and use the entertainment as the mode. "Entertainment" games have an entertainment goal first, and use learning as the mode. Game designers have little concern for the skills, knowledge, or enduring understanding that their players have, so long as they understand enough/the right things to progress through the game. Educationalists, however, have a deep-seeded need to see success in an enduring understanding that was often chosen outside of the game mechanic entirely.

Thomas and Brown begin to touch on how this can be resolved, by understanding that the imposition of external learning forces for a game serves little, if not a negative, effect on the learning outcome of the game. Instead, they suggest, games have inherent learning that can be harnessed. I am inclined to subscribe to their thinking, however, I am concerned that that means we cannot use games as a tool, but rather that games will begin to decide what information can or cannot be learned (at least, through games). It almost seems lazy, to write off the ability of a game to be used as a mode in a learning objective.

I am a firm believing that game mechanics are highly effective in education. Games themselves, though, have yet to prove themselves useful in education. Or, maybe we have yet to allow them to prove themselves anything, for we're too busy telling them what they should be.

Monday, May 10, 2010

Learning, party of one.

Dillenbourg's expose on the bloated topic of "collaborative learning" is sorely needed. I know, as I was sitting to plan an activity this week, it became clear that ANYTHING COULD be collaborative learning, depending on how you spun it. He was able to pull some interesting insight from the rubble, though.

Collaboration is often thought to necessarily be between 2 or more people. However, Dillenbourg points out the Vygotskian idea of a conversation with yourself, and says that one may then feasibly collaborate with yourself. I think this is fascinating, with my own work in health and nutrition efficacy. In that realm, you're often having an internal conversation about the merits of one food or another, and ultimately you decide on a meal through a process of self-collaboration. That is the best way to describe it.

Additionally, distributed cognition was brought up, the idea that knowledge need not (and ultimately cannot) be contained within one person - or within anything. It is a set of shared practices that form a whole among many people. This is ultimately a high-level version of collaboration, unlike much of what the article was talking about, but important nevertheless.


Monday, May 3, 2010

World's biggest "computer guy"

It has been driven to the point of cliche that the internet has brought people together in new ways, but the material that we've read suggest that it has also brought them together in distinctly old ways. The actions with which users are engaging one another on the internet is not so much a new paradigm, but a greatly expanded enhancement on the tried and true.

Heather A. Horst, Becky Herr-Stephenson, and Laura Robinson write to the effect that young people are organizing socially online, and searching for information, in many of the same ways that they once did. However, as the tecnology has made such information gathering considerably easier, and thus increased both social connections, and legitimate peripheral participation.

The biggest implications for education are of that latter potion, legitimate peripheral participation. Until recently, one had to be a "geek" to have access to the information and people necessary to understand many of the high tech gadgets available today. However, with this access to the same resources, documentation, and user-generated information, some are able to do things they never imagined they would be able to do. This not only has the ability to transform actions, but attitudes.

Much of the research on educational policy is on the inequalities that different groups have in their uptake one subjects such as those from the STEM categories. Policy makers would be wise to eye this increase in peripheral participation as an opportunity to even the playing field with those that have, until now, held the reigns to information itself.

Monday, April 26, 2010

The articles on mobile information collection presented an interesting issue. Mobile devices are quickly becoming very effective information gathering tools, with rich sensor networks that are with a user at practically every moment, but that the collection of this data is, at best, something to think carefully about. The information can be very useful, but only with proper signal processing to make it so. More salient even than that, however, are the social and security concerns around this data.

I am not sure if the concerns listed in the articles are going to be as severe as they propose, though. Personal information security has changed in the digital age, and many of the users that would take part in this mobile data collection will have grown up in a time when computers and the internet were ever-present. Those people have consistently shown they are more likely to share data like income, something that was previously a strong social taboo, in order to gain advantages like informed salary negotiation.

The articles do say that these concerns may simply be a matter of not knowing, just as the doom and gloom of personal security surrounding the answering machine turned out to be little more than conjecture. On the other hand, as this data becomes more prevalent, it is also true that it has far more longevity and scope than that of a simple answering machine saying that I am not home.

In the end, I believe the benefits of a system that can better our lives through pervasive data collection far outweigh the potential pitfalls. But then again, I am one of that digital age.

Wednesday, April 21, 2010

The readings this week made it clear that searching was a major theme in the newly networked world, because so much information is immediately available, it is impossible to simply categorize it as has been the convention in the past. However, this searching paradigm does not always, or even often, work well for some segments of the population and it can be limiting.

It is suggested that kids have a hard time with search-based information retrieval, because of their limited typing skills or limited knowledge of search protocol. Search also has some seemingly paradoxical considerations for adults, too. It can be limiting to those who are looking for materials in a language that is not their own, but it can also help them to find materials in their own language that may not be available to them otherwise.

When looking through categorized materials, a foreign language piece is clearly related to those around it, and you can look for a way to get the information translated (or find a translated version). During a search, however, you have no such indication of relevance. It will be interesting to see how this trend develops, and if the search-based information system is a hinderance or a help to those that do not speak the dominant language of the material.

Wednesday, April 14, 2010

The Barbour and Reeves article lays out the expectations and realities for K12 learners in a virtual environment, and it is clear that the majority of the expectation lies on the student. The online environment is expected to make the material more available, but the triggering for study,and the motivation to do so, rest almost entirely on the student.

The successful cases listed are among students that are motivated already. However, I find this to be a cheap success, as those same students would be successful in a more traditional learning environment as well. What has a virtual environment done, except to spread material to places that it would not have gone before? The opportunities for virtual learning environments are largely unrealized if we cannot make it more than a highly-available library of information for already-motivated students.